Black Hart BBQ - Authentic Smoky Ribs, Brisket & Award-Winning Barbecue in Palmyra, NY

Best burnt ends I've ever had!! What a wonderful barbecue spot, the woman helping us was so friendly and welcoming. The inside is very nice and clean, and the food gets to you extremely fast! I wish I would have taken pictures of the food but me, and my entire family were extremely happy with the food! The awards on the wall are clearly well deserved

First time trying this place & it won't be our last! Absolutely delicious! We decided to share the Hart Attack plate since it had a little bit of everything on it and it was more than enough for 2 people! The pulled brisket was the best brisket we've had in the area! All of the meat was perfectly seasoned and smoked! The coleslaw & fried salt potatoes were absolutely delicious! The restaurant is small, but very clean & very friendly staff. The prices are on the higher end, but you get what you pay for! HIgh quality food and ingredients! We are so happy to finally find a good BBQ place in the area! We drove from Canandaigua & it was well worth the drive! Highly recommend Black Hart BBQ! We are already planning a return visit!

Best ribs and brisket I’ve ever had. I got the ribs/mac n cheese/salt potatoes. My wife got the brisket sandwich/corn muffin/ fried salt potatoes. It filled me up perfectly and was AMAZING! The lady working the register was extremely friendly. 10/10 reccomend.

Black Hart had it all for a small local BBQ place. It started out with the super friendly and helpful service. I gave Atmosphere a four because it is a simple dining experience, but the place was spotless and clean. Even the restroom. We like BBQ, having grown up in Texas, and this place nails it. We had brisket sandwiches and the beef was perfectly cooked, tender and lean. If ever in the area and you’re really hungry, give them a try and you will be happy you did. Oh, and the sides? Amazing! We had the salted potatoes fried, Mac salad, mac and cheese and baked beans. Yum!

Fantastic food with some of the best ribs I have ever had. The smokey flavor was so rich that when I licked my fingers I could still taste it. I normally use extra BBQ sauce with my ribs but the sauce they had in them was so good that I didn’t even use extra sauce. The corn bread was great. The pickles were not homemade so skip those.

We used Blackhart BBQ to cater my fathers 74th Birthday! The owner was exceptionally easy to work with and helped us make decisions based on our needs. For 14 people we ordered Brisket, Pulled Chicken, Baked Beans, Salt Potatoes, and Corn Muffins. We definitely had food left over, but we sent it home with guests and finished the leftovers the next day. The price point and amazing food were perfect and I enjoyed a day with family rather than hours of preparation and presentation. THANK YOU Blackhart! We will be back!

Had only heard good things about this place from other locals, and I'm so glad we stopped in today! The smashed and fried salt potatoes were legit - next time I've gotta try them loaded The BBQ is flavorful and juicy even before sauce is added - we got the brisket and the pulled pork - and the sandwiches are huuuge! Will absolutely be a new regular spot for us in Palmyra, 13/10 would absolutely recommend!!

Service was exceptional. Food was even better. The pulled brisket is actually better than the sliced brisket. The beans n brisket is awesome! Not lacking any brisket! The last st the counter I'm so sorry I forgot her name. She is the sweetest lady ever. Kind and funny too! Also if u do not get the burnt turkey ends u are totally cheating yourself! Totally! Turkey burnt ends did not make the picture...I ate them!